Well
friends, the world championships are officially over which means I can focus
again on other things. One of those things? The 2017 Etrain Team Rankings. As I
mentioned previously, I’ll be combining the rankings that you guys put up on
the blog with my own to create a group team rankings to start the season. Now I
only used posts that actually had state wide rankings to create the “commenter”
rankings. If you made a note but didn’t actually provide full rankings, I read
your note, in most cases I learned something from your note (lots of insightful
stuff) and I incorporated that into my thinking for my own rankings, but there
was not a reasonable mathematical formula to apply to the rankings for those
type of comments. So I left them out. For my own rankings, I only went up to
top 10 so if you see an “N/A” for my ranking it could mean anything from 11th
to 111th (although I would bet closer to the former).
Anyway,
without further ado, here are the top 10 rankings for each classification.
Remember to check out the returners cheat
sheets as well as the bulletin board
material post for lots more feedback on just about every team around the
state.
A
Honorable
Mention: Masterman (ET: 10, Comments:
N/A)
10. Elk Lake (ET: N/A, Comments: 8)
Elk
Lake is a consistent, excellent program with some proven talent in Peyton Jones
and Cody Oswald. They were both top 50 finishers in the state last year. The
difficult question for Elk Lake will, of course, be making it out of their loaded
district as Montrose is looming as a state title contender once again.
9. Riverview (ET: 9, Comments: 10)
The
WPIAL has been consistently strong in A, having the top two teams in the state
as recently as 2014. Riverview has spent the past few seasons gaining
experience on the state course and their front runners are improving at the
right time. Ben Barnes shines as the returning state medalist, but there could be
a breakout from Michael Komaniak or Ryan Cecil this year that takes this team
to another level.
8. Seneca (ET: 8, Comments: 9)
Seneca
will be an interesting team to watch this upcoming fall. They lose the three
key components of their state title contending squads in the Myers twins and
Adam Hanes, but they do return a lot of other quality pieces who spent time
developing under the Seniors leadership. The question becomes, will this team
continue to move forward without their stars or will they struggle to find an
identity? Personally, I think this team is going to continue to excel and win
the district once again, however, it’s a tall order to ask for a team that
loses it’s big three. I think Jake Schneider is the name to watch on this
roster, but don’t sleep on Brock Smith either.
7. NE Bradford (ET: 6, Comments: 6)
The
District 4 powerhouse is still probably my pick to make states, but they will
get everything they can handle from Southern Columbia. I like the depth, I like
the potential for some of their young guys to step up (especially some of the
younger brothers on the roster), but they will have an uphill battle just to
make the championships. Zak Smith looks like a sleeper pick for a state medal,
but Mosier or Moore (or someone else we don’t know) will need to become a top
50 guy as well if this team is going to continue a remarkable top 5 streak.
6. Southern Columbia (ET: 5,
Comments: 7)
I’m
very high on this squad as exhibited by my top 5 ranking. They showed at
Foundation last fall that all they need to be a top 5 team in A is an
opportunity. Ethan Knoebel has the potential to be a top 10 guy in the state
(maybe even top 5) after a terrific sophomore campaign and Nick Kuzo is no
slouch as a #2. They return a hungry pack that has been chomping at the bit to
rematch NEB and punch a ticket to states.
5. Jenkintown (ET: 7, Comments: 4)
It’s
hard to discount a team that returns two state medalists, including a guy who
was top 10 in the state as a sophomore in Jack Miller. Jenkintown seems on the
way up, but they need to prove they can restock the back end of their depth.
They lost some key pieces to graduation and, with small schools, having depth
is not always a guarantee, even at the top programs. However, their front
running and experience makes me feel pretty confident about another top 10
finish for this squad, assuming they survive the challenge from District rivals
Christopher Dock.
4. Penns Valley (ET: 4, Comments:
5)
I’m
super high on this team. I’m a big believer in Penns Valley, a squad that has
been consistently improving each year, led by their all-star Chris Colwell.
Colwell and Bierley give this squad one of the best 1-2 punches in the state
and the pack behind them has the potential to be excellent. They’ve got
experience, they’ve got depth and, if one guy makes a jump, they could be
competing for team medals in November.
3. Montrose (ET: 3, Comments: 3)
I’m
going to sound like a broken record, but Montrose was really good last year.
Like really, really good. In a pretty solid district, they absolutely dominated
the district meet. They had depth stretching past the varsity squad and into JV
and they handled a loaded group in their first appearance in A. However, at
states they didn’t have their best day and they were on the outside looking in
for the medals. To compound that, they lost a lot of their firepower out front
in Mead and Brewer. I still feel good about their chances this year considering
their remarkable depth for a small school, plus their extra experience and motivation
from their defeat last year.
2. Elk County Catholic (ET: 2,
Comments: 2)
Elk County
Catholic doesn’t get a ton of talk behind Winchester Thurston, but people are
starting to notice how good this program is. They got a #1 vote over WT in the
preseason rankings and last year’s runner-ups have caught my attention as well.
I think Ben Hoffman could be a superstar this season after a terrific freshman
season and his fellow rising sophomore Isaac Wortman could be a top 35 type as
well. The top 4, on paper, is the best in the state. If they get a #5 and their
sophomores can handle the spotlight, look out.
1. Winchester Thurston (ET: 1,
Comments: 1)
It’s easy to see why
Winchester Thurston is the #1 team on both of our rankings. They’ve won two
state titles in three years. They absolutely dominated every small school race they
competed in last year. They’ve put 3 guys on the medal stand in each of the
past two seasons as well. With three top 50 guys coming back and some other young
pieces returning as well, it’s hard to bet against this proven program.
However, we’ve seen that even the best programs can slip when injuries come
into play. WT knows all about that from their 2014 and 2015 runs. Hopefully
this team stays healthy and we get to see what they can do. Also, keep your
eyes out for a breakout freshman to come from this roster. They’ve produced
some of the best in the state the past few years, including Tristan Forsythe,
who is now a senior looking to grab his first individual title on the XC
trails.
AA
Honorable
Mention: Pope John Paul (ET: 10,
Commenters: N/A), Milton (ET: N/A,
Commenters: 9), General McLane (ET: N/A,
Commenters: 10)
10. Central Cambria (ET: 9,
Commenters: N/A)
Central
Cambria didn’t get a lot of love from the commenters in the build up to these
rankings, but I’m a fan of this squad’s potential. They are still very young
and potentially inexperienced, but there is too much talent here to ignore. My
projected top 5 for this squad includes two sophomores and two juniors, any of which
could be the breakout stars of 2017. Plus, I think this district in general
could take a nice step forward. Most of the top guys return including Garrett
Baublitz and that should allow the big names to push each other and work toward
faster times throughout the season. Just ask District 3 how much that can make
a difference.
9. Greensburg Salem (ET: N/A,
Commenters: 6)
This
team has officially become a household name after a terrific 2016-2017 that
included a WPIAL championship and a 7:51 4x800. However, Greensburg Salem has
lost a key piece to that success in Frankie King and the GS boys will need to
add to their depth if they are going to replace him. The good news is they have
one of the best top 3s in the state in the Bindas and Mark Brown, all three of
which are entering their junior years after huge track success. If they get a
4-5, look out.
8. Grove City (ET: 5, Commenters:
N/A)
Although
this team is a year in and year out contender, I don’t think they made it onto
any of the commenter rankings this offseason. Yes, it’s easy to forget about
these guys because they missed out on states last year, but let’s keep in mind
this program is historically always a contender for a top 5 spot in the state
(and usually more). Plus, it’s not like they don’t bring back any talent. Most
notably, they have Jonah Powell, a potential state champion candidate in 2017,
but also Tyler Quinn, Mason Murray and Luke Owrey. The disappointment of
missing states last year is probably still fresh in this group’s mind and it
wouldn’t surprise me if they use that as fuel for a run into the top 3 at
states.
7. Holy Redeemer (ET: 8,
Commenters: 7)
Holy
Redeemer was one of the pleasant surprises of district week last year and
backed it up with a great run at states. They have a couple rising juniors with
a ton of talent in Zapusek and Volpetti who they will lean on heavily, but they
also return some nice depth to round out the roster. This squad should really benefit
from going up against top teams like Dallas, Tunkhannock and Berwick on a
consistent basis in District 2 and, even in what should be a loaded year for
the AA classification, it’s hard to imagine this team outside the top 10 given their
talent.
6. New Castle (ET: 6, Commenters:
8)
I
really like this team. They were sneaky good last year, nearly defeating South
Fayette (who went on to be 3rd at states) at WPIALs. They had a
terrific pack last year and return a good chunk of it. Rising sophomore Anthony
Litrenta has the potential to be a star this year, but the real wildcard name
to watch is Le’Shawn Huff. This kid surprised everybody with a 1600 victory at
the AAA WPIAL meet last spring and could be a real force in XC as he enters his
senior season. If he does become great, that will just make this intriguing core
even more dynamic.
5. Harbor Creek (ET: 7, Commenters:
4)
Harbor
Creek returns 3 state medalists. 3! That should be all you need to know right
there about this program. However, they do need to solidify the back half of
the roster. Plus, it will be nice to have a little insurance policy so that there
isn’t too much pressure for all of the top pieces to run out of their mind.
Harbor Creek is a strong program and I think they have the potential to bolster
the back half of the lineup and become top 5 contenders again, but nothing is a
given. I’m excited to see how this team looks when they start the season. Regardless,
that top 3 is so impressive, I have a hard time betting against these guys.
They may end up with 3 in the top 15 this year.
4. Wyomissing (ET: 4, Commenters:
5)
I’m
very excited about Wyomissing’s potential. They just barely missed my top 3.
Joe Cullen is already a star as the reigning district champion so the key for
this team is their other pieces. Rising sophomore Ben Kuhn has shown flashes of
brilliance already and he only just finished his freshman year. Matt Driben
could be an x-factor if he jumps into the XC line up after a monster track
season. Plus, Wyomissing will have a great measuring stick in house in York
Suburban that should help push them and show them what it takes to be elite.
They have to prove that their potential can be realized, but the upside here is
undeniable.
3. South Fayette (ET: 3,
Commenters: 3)
South
Fayette had one of the best races of the weekend at states last year. They
finished 3rd in a loaded AA race and nearly stole team medals away
from York Suburban. One of the more obvious keys to their success was the
excellent front running of Sam Snodgrass and Aaron Pfeil (now graduated), but
what took them over the top was their consistent pack running to round out the
top 5. Silas Mays and Michael Cusick will have to bring that same clutch factor
to the 2017 season if this team wants to make up for the big whole left by
Pfeil’s graduation. I’m excited to see if they can take over the WPIAL or if
another squad will rise to challenge the early season favorite.
2. York Suburban (ET: 2,
Commenters: 2)
1. Dallas (ET: 1, Commenters: 1)
Stop me if you’ve
heard this one before: Dallas and York Suburban are two terrific teams, returning
a lot of fantastic runners for programs with state championship pedigree. It’s
unbelievable how strong these two squads have been year in and year out for the
past 4 seasons! Dallas is going for a crazy strong three-peat and yet, if
Dallas wasn’t around, York Suburban would be the heavy favorites for a
four-peat! Although I think Dallas is better right now (and they have the
advantage of winning the last two titles), I really like York Suburban’s early
season odds for knocking them off. The difference this year will likely be the
#5 spot. Both teams lost a key senior contributor, so someone else will need to
step up and fill that role. Even with all the firepower out front, this is a
great reminder that XC usually comes down to the unsung heroes.
AAA
Honorable
Mention: North Penn (ET: 8,
Commenters: N/A), Southern Lehigh
(ET: N/A, Commenters: 9), Abington
Heights (ET: N/A, Commenters: 10)
10. State College (ET: 6,
Commenters: N/A)
As you’ve
probably guessed, the team rankings are a bit all over the place as we enter
the season. State College, who is #5 on my board right now, is on the outside
looking in for a lot of people. The #5 spot may be a little bold, but I think
it’s a fairly wide open discussion and I’ll hang my hat on a team that 1) has
two potential all-star talents to front run, 2) has proven they can put
together a top 5-7 program with some consistency, and 3) has good experience.
However, State College still needs to prove they can bolster their back end
depth enough outlast some of the District One powers, needs to hopefully keep
everyone healthy and, most importantly, outlast Mifflin County in what should
be an exciting district match up.
North
Penn was the other team that almost made this spot on the list. I love the
North Penn upside (excellent core, younger guys on the rise), but I just need
to see it from start to finish this season. I think the peak for this squad is
a top 5 finish in the state, but they could just easily be fighting for their
life just to make it to Hershey.
9. Butler (ET: 4, Commenters: N/A)
As far
as I could tell, Butler has only received one vote from the commenters and it
was a #10 spot. I guess I’m missing something here as I see the Bull Dogs (I
make up team mascots so I apologize when this is wrong) as a Cinderella story
in 2017. This squad returns a fantastic core. They have a great front runner.
They are confident, experienced and peak at the right time. There doesn’t seem
like a lot of downside. That being said, Butler is in a district where it will
be tricky just to advance to Hershey. They also weren’t a top 10 team last year
at states and they aren’t the household name that other top programs are. Maybe
those factors will end up mattering and maybe that’s why they haven’t gotten
quite as much commenter love, but I’m on board.
8. Henderson (ET: N/A, Commenters:
4)
Henderson
is basically the opposite of Butler. I had Henderson just outside my top 10
while the Warriors were one of just two programs to show up on every list that
was presented by you commenters (the other being CR North). They have
championship pedigree, a great front runner and a nice core that was a top 10
team in the state last year. At least one guy has to step up if they want top 5
in the state and, ideally, they need 3 guys around the top 50. The thing is the
5 district one teams to qualify for states have been top 10 at states every
year since the move to three classifications. Henderson has made states every
year since the move to three classifications. So it makes sense that this team
is in the top 10.
7. North Allegheny (ET: 10,
Commenters: 6)
North
Allegheny is another team with a legendary reputation. Last year they took 6th
in the state and it was a huge surprise to see them outside the top 5. Pretty
wild to think about considering they didn’t have many guys who could clock sub
17 minute times for 5k and they still jumped up to 6th in final
standings. NA has graduated so many elite guys over the years and the other top
programs in the state have been loading up with young talent, so it’s
reasonable to expect these guys to slip. But that’s not how the Tigers have
operated. They have always been district title contenders and near top 5 in the
state. Bet against NA at your own risk.
6. Mount Lebanon (ET: 9,
Commenters: 7)
On
paper, this Mount Lebanon team looks really strong. They’ve got 5 sub 17 guys
back. They have rising sophomore who made states as a freshman last season. The
track times posted by this group were excellent including multiple guys in the
low 4:30s or near 10 flat for one and two miles respectively. If this were a
district one team, they’d probably be getting more hype on here. However, Lebo
has struggled at districts and the WPIAL is loaded at the top this season. Personally,
I’d love to see them atop the podium in Coopers, proving to everyone they’ve
exercised their demons, but it’s a long way to go between now and districts.
5. Shanahan (ET: 7, Commenters: 5)
When
this team is clicking, it’s something special to behold. At districts last
year, when everyone was coming around to be healthy and focused, Shanahan
looked excellent with 5 returners under 17 minutes. On the track, when the team
was ready to roll, the 4x8 grabbed a surprise indoor state medal without their
best runner. There’s so much talent on this roster including the obvious super
star in Josh Hoey, but also some lesser known stand outs like Logan Yoquinto.
The former AA school isn’t quite as deep as many of their AAA counterparts so
they need to be firing on all cylinders to keep their hold on this ranking, but
the talent is undeniable. Jack Ettien, Jonah Hoey and Jon McGrory will be the
swing voters this year. If they can get to the low 16s, this team will be
really good.
4. LaSalle (ET: 3, Commenters: 8)
I think
this LaSalle squad is being slept on hard. Yes, they lose a lot of key pieces
from last year’s team, but what you can’t underestimate is this team’s depth.
At the ’16 state meet, LaSalle’s top two runners had off days and they still
rallied and got 5th overall with a tight pack. They return “just” 3
varsity guys but they are two talented rising sophomores (imagine how good you
are to make LaSalle’s varsity as a frosh?) and an all-star in reigning district
champ Evan Addison. If you look down their track roster there is a ton of potential
as well. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if LaSalle is in the state title
discussion by October.
3. DT West (ET: 5, Commenters: 3)
Well,
it’s official. Downingtown West has reached “elite program” status. In the past,
people have said Henderson, North Allegheny, CR North and others have been
praised for their consistent success, regardless of returning talent. Those
schools are typically lauded in preseason rankings without needing to look at
the roster. Well, DT West has entered that realm. The commenters ranked this
school 3rd and I gave them a top 5 spot despite the fact that they
return just 1 varsity runner from their 3rd place team in the state.
And, although I think Tyler Rollins is going to be very good this year, he wasn’t
a top 50 guy in AAA and I don’t believe he would have been an individual state
qualifier out of District One. Yet still, we all think this team is going to be
good again this year.
Here’s
the thing, despite DT West’s losses, they have plenty of talent coming back.
This school was incredibly deep last year down to the JV and the freshman teams
in elite invitationals. And guys like Rollins, Kaiser, Sewall and Chamoun all
put down serious marks on the track that indicate they could be excellent
pieces in a run at states again this year. So basically, I’m perfectly comfortable
with the ranking by the commenters. Shout out to DT West and welcome to the
elite programs club. Now go out and back up the reputation.
2. Seneca Valley (ET: 2,
Commenters: 2)
It was
a huge 2016-2017 for Seneca Valley. They toppled North Allegheny at WPIALs in a
decade defining event and then turned around and became the districts top 4x8
squad with multiple school record runs at states. And get this-they bring back
basically everybody who made those achievements possible. Seneca Valley is very
legit and has an ascending 1-2 punch in juniors Sam Owori and Seth Ketler. They
also bring back Alex Dixon and Christian Resch who were top 25 guys in the
WPIAL last season. Andrew Balla, Luke Bellack, Adam Owori and Aidan Domencic
each showed flashes of potential to step in a become a strong #5 runner (or
perhaps more). I really like this team and think they can be gold medalists in
November.
However,
there will be some pressure now that they are on top. Seneca Valley will have a
target on their back and the rest of the WPIAL (and the state) will be out to
topple this budding powerhouse. I’m sure North Allegheny is hungry for a
rematch and Butler would love to beat SV to establish themselves as a true
contender. How will they handle the pressure of expectation? Will the juniors
be ready to lead the team now that Trey Razanauskas is graduated? Those are
perhaps the more pressing questions for this squad as clearly, the talent and
pedigree is on the roster.
1. CR North (ET: 1, Commenters: 1)
The
unanimous preseason #1 is the defending state champions from CR North. Back to
back champions aren’t rare: we’ve seen them in 2012-2013 and 2007-2008 in AAA.
Dallas is fresh off back to back titles themselves in AA. So it wouldn’t be a
jaw dropper for a team with the consistent success of CRN to grab another gold
in 2017. They have plenty of front running talent to get the job done as Ryan
Campbell is a state title contender, Sam Early is an ascending state medalist
and Ethan Koza is a jack of all trades 16 flat guy. It’s actually the depth
that could be the biggest concern as, after Kevin Ehrgott, they don’t return a
lot of low 16 types.
I’ll
tell you this right now, CRN will likely not look like a title team for the first
month of the season. This squad is notorious for looking (relatively) flat
early before turning it on down the stretch to produce top 5 type results.
Plenty of teams know how to peak at the right time, but perhaps none peak so
dramatically as CR North does, going from left for dead to title contender in
the blink of an eye. So feel free to
jump off the bandwagon if you’d like during the early season, but remember that
come late October, CR North will be ready to chase the title.